Here’s another unpublished blog post from the archives ….
My children. My 7 year old inquisitive and energetic little girl and my independent yet cuddly 3 yr old boy. The gems of my life. From the day I held my firstborn – my 6 lb 4 oz baby girl - my life was forever changed with the awesome yet terrifying privilege of raising this tiny being who would hold the strings to my heart. The birth of my daughter in 2004 and my son in 2008 seemed to confirm a greater purpose in this world given by Christianity, and fueled a passion to know more and instill in them that same purpose.
| All dressed up for her ballet recital! |
If my quandary about religion was not hard enough, I have the added obligation, particularly while we homeschool, of teaching my daughter the history of mankind, a story riddled with manmade horrors as slavery, war, crime, poverty, and worst of all, religious bloodshed, all of which still linger today. Try explaining to a 7 year old why people took slaves, separating mother from child.
A popular homeschooling curriculum (the classical approach) promotes a chronological teaching of history, such that my daughter would have learned about the ancient cultures this past school year (1st grade), and will end with the modern cultures in fourth grade. A common option used by both the Christian and secular homeschool communities are Susan Bauer Wise's Story of the World texts. Each time I have browsed them, I’ve cringed at the thought of how to teach my daughter, for instance, about the Egyptian gods while diverting the unavoidable questions about the differences between the Christian God and their gods. I keep taking the path of least resistance, which means focusing on all the other subjects and completely neglecting history. Two problems solved – I get to protect my sensitive daughter from extensive discussion about manmade evils, AND avoid difficult conversation about Christianity.
I can’t do this forever.
| Enjoying our local botanical gardens while sister is in a class. |
How can I protect my children from both the madness and the mystery? How can I protect their joyful ignorance? Their innocent faces tempt me to stifle the questions and offer them a vision of spirituality AND history under rose-colored glasses. But I can’t erase reality, and the loss of their ignorance will proceed year by year. It has already started with my daughter. All I can do is love them, hug them, cry with them and embrace their questions without distancing them with pat answers and authority. Instill in them a passion to cultivate empathy, charity and humility. Respect them enough to have the courage to tackle difficult topics, perhaps even the Story of the World curriculum that I dread.
Here's a song that puts to music the thoughts expressed here - "In my Arms" by Plumb.
Here are a couple of thoughts:
ReplyDelete1. I like what one Bible scholar, Thomas Thompson, said that he did: He just read his kids stories. All kinds of stories---the Bible, Gilgamesh, etc.
2. I wrote a post a while back wondering how I would teach my children about faith, when I do not know what my own faith is. I don't have children, or even a spouse right now, so it's not a pressing concern for me, as it is for you. But I do wonder about it. A commenter replied that what he does is tell his child about the various points-of-view out there, then he says what his point-of-view is.
I've encountered this sort of approach in other places. For example, I worked one summer at a program sponsored by the Presbyterian Church (USA), and there was a Jewish lady who was working there, too. She wondered what she should do if a child asked her a question about faith, and someone suggested that she give her answer, then take the child to other adults so that the child can hear other answers. I think it's good to prepare kids for the fact that there are different people in the world.
At the same time, I wouldn't want my children to get involved in the occult, so there would be a limit to my broad-mindedness.
I hope you can find something helpful in what I just wrote. Blessings to you!
Hi, I was perusing my daughter's blog and came across your post. I really feel moved to share something with you. I understand and can sympathize with your wondering about God's love for us. I appreciate your open hearted honesty about your doubts and concerns, especially relating to your beautiful children.
ReplyDeleteHaving said that, I urge you to think about what I just said. Where does that devotion, concern and love for your children come from?
I believe that God, in His infinite wisdom and love, when He created us in His image, gave us this same template.
What I mean to say is this: He gave us the immeasurably beautiful gift of procreation and, at the same time, told us that He is our Father. So, when I read your blog about your complete devotion to and love of your children, the first thought that jumps into my mind is this: Doesn't she realize the source of this???
If we were the remnants of some great cataclysmic "great bang," a bunch of atoms sown together by chance and fortune, how do we explain the incredible, mind-boggling, totally self-sacrificing love that we have for our children. Makes no sense to me!
Kindest regards
Jim
This particular subject fuels my own doubt. While I don't have children now, I hope to in the future and I wondered just what I would teach them about the origin of mankind, Jesus, heaven and hell. I'm obviously not in that position, yet, but I can certainly understand the ambivalence. {{{LAC}}}
ReplyDeleteThis is a tough subject. I vascillate between avoidance and engagement. I'm starting to introduce more tentativeness to my kids about how we interpret scripture, often explaining that scripture is man's best understanding about God. My son has already been bothered by the discrepancy in the Genesis account with the fact that dinosaurs were extinct millions of years before humans entered the scene. I do talk about a variety of beliefs, which is easy to do given my son's exposure to a number of cultures. I've also introduced yoga to my boys (only somewhat successfully). with that being said, I do think it's good for kids to be grounded in one way of conceptualizing the world before learning about too many world views. I think learning to function within a worldview then gives you the cognitive tools to explore another. Of course, which world view to pick is another matter.
ReplyDeleteThat's a beautiful song LAC. My children are young adults so I now have to worry about them in a different way - before too long I guess I'll be hoping they'll sing something like that song to me.
ReplyDeleteI have read and heard that we are in an era of overprotective parenting. My wife and I were certainly very protective of our children and the impulse is still there when they're in their 20s. Our parents were nowhere near as protective of us - the things we got up to would have been pretty much impossible for our children.
I wonder now if this is a good thing. Children are an often surprising mix of fragility and relience. They get hurt more easily but also heal more quickly in a physical sense. I think something similar happens psychologically. Things that are beyond their ability to process, like the nature of God, just go over their heads. Little things that we see as trivial bother them immensely - like whether their sandwiches are cut in squares or triangles. Just when you think they need protecting you find they are way ahead of you!
What IS the difference between Egyptian gods and the Xian god(s)?
ReplyDeleteI'm pretty sure the egyptians thought their gods were the true ones, too.
So did the Greeks, and the Romans, and the Assyrians....
James: Thank you for sharing. I do indeed find them helpful. It is important to set the example of having an open & honest relationship with your children, and that includes being vulnerable about my doubts.
ReplyDeleteJim: Thank you for stopping by. I agree that being a mom to these precious children makes me want to believe in a higher power, and one of the reasons i am an agnostic and not an atheist. That said, my struggles really focus on the nature of Jesus in light of all the modern biblical research, archeology, etc.
Dma: Well, I do hope you will have a reason to confront this challenge of talking to your children! From reading your most recent post, it sound like you are considering trying for children:)
DoOrDoNot: I do agree that sometimes you have to choose a worldview. The issue for us is especially complex while we homeschool. I have to ensure she gets socialized, and as such, need to join and be active in homeschool groups. The problem-- well, all the groups are segregated and fundamentalist Christian or fundamentalist liberal, and I fit nowhere! I cannot join the Christian groups b/c of inerrancy clauses, and I find am not crunchy enough for other groups. The christian group's email list has parents bashing evolution and people that wear bathing suit bottoms that aren't shorts, and the other group has parents advocating for boy/girl sleepovers (i.e. Teenage sex). Where do I fit in here, as an agnostic mom who will promote chastity?
Jon: Your observations have been very true for my children thus far. An "I don't know" response to their questions about God is often sufficient....but "I don't know" in response to going to the pool might bring on some tears:). Oh...and i have a collection of sandwich cutters to form hearts, triangles, squares, and even a bear, for my finicky eaters:)
Annie: Very true. Pluralism is a big doubt producer for me.
My kids are still young enough that I don't think about these things too much, but I do try to follow the recommendations found in Waldorf education about using fairy tales to introduce the concept of morals. Here is an good article: http://thewonderofchildhood.com/2011/02/fairy-tales-with-christine-natale/
ReplyDeleteI don't know that I have anything that will be helpful - just know I am sharing from my heart.
ReplyDeleteWhen my children were very small (I had 3 in 3 years) I cried out to God to show me how to raise them so they would walk with Him all of their days into eternity. He has taken me on a journey that has been unbelieveable - today my three kids are in their 40ties and are walking with Him and raising their children to do so.
One thing I had going for me was that I don't have the intellect that you have. I think that it is much more difficult to BELIEVE when you have a great intellect. At a prayer meeting one night a man who was intellectually challenged rose and said to the group, "I know that you all feel sorry for me because I can't think like you do. Don't ever feel sorry for me because my mind doesn't get between me and my Jesus like your minds do."
What an ah-ha moment for me. I am in no way saying that your intellect is bad - it was given to you by God, so it definitely isn't bad. However, it may make it more of a challenge to fully understand how God works. That sounds weird doesn't it LOL. Shouldn't the brilliant be able to understand more?
Not according to God. 1 Corinthians 18-30
I liked what you said - that maybe you could use this struggle to help others who are going through the same thing. That could be very well the reason for your struggle. I don't know.
Do you truly want to know the truth even if it means going against your pride, your earthly knowledge. Are you willing to give up control of everything? That is the foundation of the Beatitudes - the first one is about giving up total control and everything else rests on that.
I am writing a Children's Ministry Curriculum that goes through the Bible. The first year shows how God has orchestrated everything from the beginning. It has been an amazing time for me as I have walked through and seen things I have never seen before.
I have come to the conclusion that(I'm still working on this so this is more a brainstorming type of statement than that i fully believe it)God is in full control and He places each individual where He wants them to bring Himself glory and to fulfill His plan. Our responsibility is our we will respond to His will for our life. Important here is submiting to the truth that God is God and we are mere humans - there is no way we can fully understand what He is doing. We are called to walk with Him in Faith.
I believe He has given us plenty of proof throughout history to show He is in control overall - Israel being a nation again is one of the biggies. There is no way if everything was just an accident or that humans were controlling things that that could have been predicted and then to actually happen. Such a tiny group of people. They are the only people in all of history to be reunited.
You have mentioned wanting something for your kids - take a look at the curriculum I'm working on. https://www.box.net/files#/files/0/f/39483760/06SundayPlusSample
If you are interested I would love to interact with you to learn from you. To learn what has caused the doubts beyond the intellectual questions. wanda@kidtrek.org
Take a look through my blog www.kidtrek-sundayplus.org It is written to believers so I don't know that it would be helpful in your struggle. I would suppose it would be too simple minded :)
You talked quite a bit about protecting your children - here is one story that addresses that and i think it rings true if you believe in God or not. http://www.kidtrek-sundayplus.org/2010/11/21/child-discipleship-do-we-over-protect-our-children/
Dear LAC,
ReplyDeleteI found this page while googling my own name, which I do from time to time to see what is going on out there with some of my work. I usually find wonderful, lovely homeschool and/ or Waldorf moms' blogs and I try to connect and make friends.
I really understand your angst. I don't want to offer any "instant iced tea" answers, but I would be happy to share a lot of what I have already produced that touches upon this subject of religion in the lives and education of our children, as well as in the understanding of our own pursuit of Faith.
I belong to no church or religion per se, except to state that I do consider myself a Christian, albeit a very heretical one.
Here is a link to a very basic article I wrote a long time ago outlining the role of Religion in Waldorf Education, as I understand and experience it. I hope that seeing the questions laid out in a kind of "time line" referring to what is considered in Waldorf Education to belong to each developmental stage may give a kind of "pressure cooker" release. Everything doesn't have to be (and in my opinion) shouldn't be presented and discussed with children all at once. That is not to say that one shouldn't answer a direct question that arises in the course of everyday life. But then, one can promise to go deeper into certain questions as the child gets a bit older instead of sidestepping it altogether.
I have a lot to share if you are interested. I do not wish to impose anything, only to be available to discuss these and other issues. : )
Wishing you and your family a lovely Christmas season full of Light of Mind and Warmth of Heart.
With Love,
Christine Natale
http://www.eons.com/uploads/2/0/20774441_Religion_in%20Waldorf%20Education.pdf
Wish List
ReplyDeleteI want a star of my very own -
Lord, send me a star tonight;
A golden star to light my way
And make the darkness bright.
I want a song of my very own -
Lord, send me a song today;
That I can play on a golden lyre
To chase the clouds away.
I want a child of my very own -
Lord, send me a child this morn
Who knows the way to the golden land
Where all of my dreams are born.
I want a dream of my very own -
Lord, send me a dream this year;
A golden dream of what life can be,
A dream that we all can share.
I want a love of my very own -
Lord, send such a love to me;
A golden love I may bring to God
That His child I’ll always be.
I want a Lord of my very own -
Lord, be Thou Thyself for me;
And teach me to walk in Thy golden Way
From now through eternity.
1987
Christine Natale